Skip to main content

Bihar Liquor Ban - The Political Perspective


Whether you call it Nitish Kumar's masterstroke for gaining publicity and support of people or a responsible chief minister batting for people's interests, on the face of it, it is great that Bihar is free from alcohol abuse.
The Bihar excise (amendment) act, 2016 – a very old 1915 act has been converted into a very stringent law – is haunting the alcohol gang of Bihar. This law banned manufacturing, selling or consumption of liquors (strong or mild) and even prescribes the death penalty for the manufacturer, suppliers and sellers of hooch in case of death as a result of consumption of spurious liquors. Although Biharis can drink outside state boundary, they'll be punished if they create nuisance after returning home.

The government had actually proposed to ban only 'desi' liquors. The sale of non-country or ‘Indian Made Foreign Liquor’ (IMFL) was allowed, although, with some caveats. However, within five days, the government extended the ban to IMFL as well, making Bihar an absolutely alcohol-free state.

By taking this step, Nitish has taken a U-turn and rectified his earlier strategy. Yes, it was Nitish Kumar who allowed the liquor business to flourish in Bihar especially to the villages and semi-urban areas in order to increase revenues.  If we keep economy under consideration, without moral obligations, we'll find that Mr Kumar has made a big mistake. After all, Rs 4,000 crore, revenue is a major source of fund for a cash-starved government.

In the Bihar assembly election, 2015, Nitish Kumar had promised the caste-neutral constituency of women to ban liquors if he returned to power due to their persistent demand for it. The women voters were quite excited to about this topic. And, days after becoming Chief Minister again, Mr Kumar kept his promise with an announcement to Ban liquors showing once again that he is a "man of words".

The Government of India is running several campaigns to restrict the consumption of alcohol and other addictive substances. The government also levy a high tax on these items so that lack of money can be a reason for giving up this addiction. But, addiction is a very severe psychological disease. For a serious drunkard, alcohol is a matter of "life or death". Lack of money cannot diminish his cravings for alcohol.

By taking away alcohol from a hard-core alcoholic, it is like taking away his life. As addiction is not just a habit but a disease, therefore an alcohol addict need a proper medical care and psychological support to get out of this euphoria.

Other states should take the cue from Bihar and follow this model as soon as possible. Liquor was one of the primary sources for generating revenue. If cash deprived Bihar government can bear the monetary loss for a good social change, other states cannot make any excuse.

Also Read: Bihar Liquor Ban - Alcoholism and Society

Labels:

Comments

  1. Unknown1 June 2016 at 08:12

    I hope that doesnt lead to increased smuggling of liquor though!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Prasant3 June 2016 at 05:53

    It’s easier to get alcohol than food in Gujarat, with home-delivered bottles often a phone call away, thanks to small local suppliers, the Hindu reported last year. Do a simple search and you get the answer - http://www.livemint.com/Politics/PminUIJiL3vo0x8K45mgfM/How-Indian-states-have-fared-in-banning-alcohol.html

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Amitesh Gupta3 June 2016 at 11:11

      Prasant, you are exaggerating things here. At least, we have a law that is empowering common people (the non-alcoholics) and curb the open sale of liquors!

      Delete
  3. Vinay Nagaraju3 June 2016 at 18:42

    Going the Gujarat way? This is interesting though. Shame that politics usually has such a large role to play in any of the decisions. I share the same fears as leena on this one though, the rise of smuggled and dangerous adulterated liquor

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

JNU - A Vision of Modern Democratic India

Through the ongoing controversy what we need to understand is that ours is a young nation still in the making which has all the ingredients to become truly a great nation, but it needs time. Give this nation that time, that gestation period and it will show the world the true meaning of greatness, one which is home to a complete spectrum of diverse culture but still thrives together with immeasurable amount of tolerance which has never been experienced anywhere else (this holds for the common citizens of India but unfortunately not for the practitioners of divisive vote-bank politics which they don’t find anti-national). Every powerful nation that exists today has gone through some sort of civil war which led to enormous violence and bloodshed. We too have our share of challenges; be it the Kashmir issue, Nagaland or Naxalism; but we have the opportunity to show the world that we can do it in a better way without any bloodshed. It is that unity in diversity that is the soul of
3 comments
Read more

Teachers Or Cheaters

We are quite aware with the Prime Minister Narendra Modi's slogan of "minimum government-maximum governance". It is one of the agenda of Modi during his campaign in 2014 general election. The place where this needs to be implemented the most is government elementary schools with slight modification as "minimum teachers-maximum teachings". Without any doubt, the government school teachers are the biggest cheaters and a burden on the economy. The salary of the government teachers is much higher than the private sector teachers (In UP, the difference is 20 times). But rather than working harder and better, the government teachers are often seen "missing in action". Karthik Muralidharan's 2014 study estimates an absence rate of 23.6 percent. When they are present, they spend much of their time in non-teaching activities or teaching with little professional competence, and exercise little effort. Some teachers don't even see for six months but d
3 comments
Read more

Forgiveness - Your Way Towards Peace

Forgiveness is a divine power, something that ordinary humans are not entitled to have. And, those who have this quality are more than 'a human'. One, who is free from materialistic desire and, most importantly, the ego, is blessed with such divine power. Whether it is of physical or mental strength, weak cannot forgive others. Forgiveness is always an attribute of strong people. It is a trait of a mature person having deep inner control over his mind. This strength cannot be bought, it has to be earned. But, how would you earn that? I think spirituality may be the answer. There are multiple benefits of forgiveness. It directly influences our thinking process. It sets you free from the negativity building around and boosts positive personality. It saves energy which can be redirected to do productive things. It is also the key to longevity and good health. But, how will you forgive someone who is not even sorry for their action? How will you respond to evil with kindn
4 comments
Read more

Why Religion Should Not Be Downplayed

When you were a child and your parents told you stories about god, you listened to that with great curiosity and excitement, but as you grow older and started seeing everything with the rational eye of science, you realise that it was a lie, and so every religious event and ritual appears to you as an act of stupidity. Still, you keep worshipping the men or women whom you were told to worship as Gods. Why? Have you considered what is the significance of religion? Religion teaches us that God has created this universe and he is running it in his own way. The Sun, The Moon, Stars, Planets, Living creatures  — bacteria, viruses, plants, animals, humans are all the creation of God. We are just doing things ordained by him. It may appear that we are influencing things, but the reality is we, ourselves, are influenced by some heavenly forces. Indians, especially Hindus, are obsessed with rituals and other religious activities like holding fast and going to temple. Some of our ritua
9 comments
Read more

Bihar Liquor Ban - Alcoholism and Society

Disclaimer : No alcohol has been used during the writing of this post. I don't know why I didn't cover this story earlier. Probably because on this topic, I didn't want to write in haste and as sayings go “better late than never”, I came up with this post. And while writing this article, sometimes I felt an alcoholic haze, that is why you should read this carefully! Let us begin with the definition of 'Alcoholism'. Casually, the process of consuming alcoholic drinks is called alcoholism. But, to be precise, alcoholism is a medical condition in which there is an abnormal addiction to alcohol, and taking it in small quantity very occasionally is not. Simply put, if you can live without alcohol, you are not an alcoholic. “Alcoholism is the effect of excessive intake of alcohol on the functions of the body and personality.” ~ W.C. Reckless “Alcoholism is a condition in which the individual has lost control over his alcohol intake in that he is constantl
1 comment
Read more

Anatomy Of Suicidal Propensity And Life's Purpose

I don't know whether committing suicide is a courageous or cowardly act. And I think, taking a specific side here would be unfair. During evolution, our thinking power enabled us to survive. But, it has also provided us an option to end a messed up life. Suicide is a very serious psychological and philosophical problem that modern humans are facing today. Legally, it is a crime. Religion, too, never permitted this act. And, as a society, we don't want people to do it. To be, or not to be, that is the question: Whether ’tis nobler in the mind to suffer The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune, Or to take arms against a sea of troubles, And by opposing, end them. To die, to sleep— But, when life becomes miserable, why would one let one's mind to suffer, when there is an option of suicide to attain peace? Why is everyone against suicide? Probably because, suicide is the violation of human survival interest. We are an adapting species and always believe tha
4 comments
Read more